In this guide, we are going to discuss what we are going to tell Sebastian in the Shadow of the Undercroft. Now the main question is, does this even matter? Will it really impact our character or the way the story progresses? We shall answer all of these questions here.
Tell Sebastian the Truth or Lie in The Shadow Of The Undercroft Quest – Hogwarts Legacy
In Hogwarts Legacy, it doesn’t appear to matter if you tell Sebastian the truth or lie in the Shadow of the Undercroft. And it’s not like you overtly lie to him; you just tell him you’re not ready to tell him everything. So you are not really denying him of the information. You are just being a bit diplomatic with your answering and that’s okay. Because it does not seem to affect the storyline at all.
However, if you want to learn the Unforgivable Curses or explore the darker side of magic, you should definitely focus on staying on Sebastian’s good side. You can learn the Cruciatus Curse and even Avada Kedavra through his quest line. So maybe it’s a good idea to tell him everything this time. It’s not required, but it’s better to be safe than sorry.
So, ultimately, that’s all you need to know about whether you should tell Sebastian the truth or lie in Hogwarts Legacy Shadow of the Undercroft. As far as we can determine, the same holds true for any decision regarding your friendship with the guy. I believe that it all comes down to a real life conversation and since the developers wanted to make it as immersive as possible, they wanted to give you the choices. Thus it seems like you are actually partaking in conversations and not just skipping cutscenes (which many of us do, in fact, when we are hungry for gameplay). This increases the level of involvement as a player. Thus, don’t worry. Denying him of information won’t take away a friend, however answering it and staying in his favour will definitely grant some favors in the future.