Tainted Grail: The Fall of Avalon has a wealth of secrets, and none are more fulfilling than the secret affair with Lady Alisa, a princess seeking a new beginning in the beleaguered South. By completing her questline, making the correct choices of dialogue, and assisting her in her endeavours, players can unlock the Yours Forever trophy, as well as a heart-wrenching love affair.
How to Get Yours’ Forever Achievement?
Meeting Lady Alisa – The One Per Cent
You first encounter Alisa in Ron’s Tavern, located behind the Horns of the South Keep. She is at a table alone and mistakes you for a server. If you compliment her dress and praise her rank, she will open up about her plans and later ask to help you obtain a coastal estate.
Assenting to her request begins The One Per Cent quest, which will send you to the Mansion by the Beach, west of Abandoned Outpost. Clear the bandits made up of a Disgraced Knight and Deranged Infantryman, and return to her. When reporting back, choose: “It’s perfectly safe, Lady Alisa.”
Farewell, Lady Alisa – A Fake Kidnapping
Alisa moves to the seaside mansion. Return and see her again, and she’ll say her husband, Duncan, has been kidnapped. This begins Farewell, Lady Alisa. Follow the quest marker east of King’s Road, battle through the undead, and go into the Miner’s Tunnels.
Inside, you’ll find Duncan alive and well—he faked the kidnapping to escape Alisa. He makes you fake lying for him and leaves you Duncan’s Ring as “proof” of his death. Do it in order to advance the romance.
Helping Her Stay – My Fair Lady
Go back home, and let Alisa know that Duncan has gone. She will consider selling the property, but you can persuade her to stay. Choose: “You don’t have to sell your house. Why can’t you just stay here?”
Then ask her to start a business, and My Fair Lady will commence. In helping her set up shop, she will request three things:
- Ragged Nobleman’s Doublet and Frayed Silk Gloves (found in crates near Duncan’s bench in the Miner’s Tunnels).
- 12 Seashells, dropped by Drowners found along beach areas.
Deliver the items one by one, choosing:
“No need. I’m doing this to help you,” and “I always listen to you, Alisa,” when prompted. Then offer to go somewhere together.
The Pavilion Date – Choosing the Right Words
Then, you’ll repair the deck outside her home (prices Wood, which you can find at locations like Horns of the South Keep). Next, she agrees to go on a date.
During the date, use these responses to charm her:
- I tried magic.
- Some magic is forbidden, but not everything.
- I didn’t think that you were a religious person.
- As a matter of course, meeting you, Alisa.
- I saw a sea monster.
- It was enormous, bigger than a vessel.
- Alisa, do you intend to spend more time with me?
If you make the correct decision, the night concludes on a warm note, and your relationship becomes stronger.
Unlocking the Achievement – Yours Forever
Return to the mansion later to find Alisa waiting with a present. Choose the following:
- “Alisa, is this a courting gift?”
- “Alisa, are you blushing?”
- “I thought love was beneath you.”
- “I’ve grown quite fond of you, too, Alisa.”
If everything has gone according to plan, the Yours Forever achievement will be triggered, and Alisa will begin referring to you as “darling.” You’ll also begin the new quest, ‘Stone by Stone,’ which involves redecorating her home together.
