There, in the Veilguard, players are confronted with the heart-wrenching decision to punish Illario-the manipulative force behind Lucanis’s torment or to rescue Caterina, who was a victim caught in the crossfire. This apparently impactful decision culminates into the same result, though the result is the newly found unification between Lucanis and Spite, bound together by a newfound understanding. Let’s go a little deeper into the intricacies of this choice and its consequences.
Should You Punish Illario or Save Caterina
The decision to either punish Illario or save Caterina comes towards the end of the “Inner Demons” quest, just after you find Lucanis. “Inner Demons” is a side quest in Dragon Age Veilguard (DAV) that focuses on the character Lucanis. You can find this quest at the Lighthouse. You can start a romantic relationship with Lucanis during the “Inner Demons” quest. However, you’ll need to have made the right choices during the “Bloodbath” quest and completed the “Unwanted Guests” main quest first. This means you won’t be able to start a romance with Lucanis until later in the game.
Once you reach the Entrance Hall, follow the blue quest marker to the Ossuary. Inside, you’ll find Lucanis’s cell, sealed with a red aura. After interacting with the seal, you’ll have a conversation with Caterina and Spite. With Caterina’s help, you’ll try to free Lucanis. However, Harding, Neve, and Illario will appear one by one, expressing doubts about your decision. Despite their concerns, you’ll eventually find Lucanis. He insists on staying in the cell to protect others. No matter whether you choose to punish Illario or save Caterina, you’ll be able to convince Lucanis to leave the cell with you.
Should You Punish Illario
When they choose this option, Lucanis and Spite put aside their disagreements to unite against their common enemy, Illario. They join forces, merging their powers, and then leave the mental world with Rook.
Should You Save Caterina
Similarly, when they decide to save Caterina, Lucanis and Spite agree to put their differences aside. Caterina suggests they search for Lucanis’ grandmother as a way to move forward. Because you helped them reach an understanding. Lucanis and Spite continue to strengthen their bond.
Whether they choose to punish Illario or save Caterina doesn’t change the outcome of this quest or the game. In the end, Lucanis and Strife reconcile, form a strong bond, and work together to uncover the truth about Illario and Caterina.
